Shocking Internet Hoax: A Heterosexual Married Man Pretends To Be A Syrian Lesbian On Internet Until He Got Caught!!!

June 13, 2011   

THE ROAD TO THE “GAY GIRL IN DAMASCUS”

Posted by 
tom-macmaster.jpgLet’s start with what is a sound assumption: there are gay girls in Damascus, a city of more than a million and a half people with—at least until the regime started shutting things down—strong international connections. But the “Gay Girl in Damascus,” the supposed author of a certain blog, is not any of those things: he is a married American man in Scotland, one who has yet to acknowledge the way he may have hurt the sort of woman he was pretending to be. Her name was supposedly Amina Araf al Omari; his is Tom MacMaster. His hoax unravelled when he claimed that Amina had been detained by security forces, and people around the world rushed to her aid, only to find no one there. (Andy Carvin, of NPR, played a key role.) MacMaster’s interview this morning with the BBC was really about one person: him. It is worth listening to, as a reminder of the way that narcissism can accompany a startling lack of self-awareness. Why did he pretend to be a Syrian-American lesbian? Because people just weren’t listening—listening to him, that is:

I really felt, a number of years ago, that in discussions on Middle East issues while living in the U.S., it was often—finding that when I presented real facts and opinions, that the immediate reaction to someone with my name was, you know, why are you anti-American, why are you anti-Jewish? Which, both are completely false…

Getting that kind of reaction was distracting from the real focus. So I invented a name to talk under that would keep the focus on the actual issues.

So he thought that he, Tom MacMaster, had an identity interesting enough to prove to be a distraction, to the extent that it needed to be hidden behind one that was suitably abstract and invisible, and that “Amina” fit the bill? There are insults wrapped in insults in this story. After all, MacMaster is not claiming that he invented Amina because she was compelling enough to get the attention he couldn’t—which she was, and that is bad enough—but that she could be enough of a cipher to allow his fascinating insights to shine through. Amina was, by his account, designed not as a muse or an idol but as an amanuensis.

Given his methods, he couldn’t accomplish even what he said that he wanted. And he may have endangered people who let down their guard trying to help Amina, as well as those who actually try to be heard. In one of his posts, Amina is saved from the secret police when her father yells at them. Who was MacMaster instructing or reproaching with that one? His confession, and partial apology, posted on his blog yesterday, was gapingly inadequate, culminating in these lines:

This experience has sadly only confirmed my feelings regarding the often superficial coverage of the Middle East and the pervasiveness of new forms of liberal Orientalism.

However, I have been deeply touched by the reactions of readers.

It is not charming to hear someone who has emotionally manipulated any number of people—not just readers of the blog, but correspondents he deceived and allowed to confide in him over the course of years—to go on about the shallowness of others. Should we feel better because we have moved him? In a followup, posted today, he begins by making some of the proper apologetic gestures, but then veers into a self-indulgent stream of discussions about his literary ambitions, how great his mother is, his fake Internet dating profiles, and how, while he “enjoyed ‘puppeting’ this woman who never was,” fake blogging “was a terrible time suck.” Girls are such trouble.

Is this an indictment of the Internet? He couldn’t have pulled precisely this hoax without it—but we’ve had hoaxes for ages. Some of the writers of anti-Catholic nun abduction stories in past centuries (also involving fanciful lesbians) might have made similarly spurious claims about the importance of their message. And the Web, when roused, was remarkably efficient at exposing MacMaster, from alerting the woman in London whose pictures he used to tell-tale Picasa accounts and I.P. addresses. Most of all, there was a stubborn belief that, if Amina did exist, she, or someone who knew her personally, must be findable via social media. That is a remarkable place to have arrived at. We assume that a gay girl in Damascus wouldn’t be alone, or unreachable. But MacMaster may have made her harder to recognize, and her situation more precarious than it needed to be.

Read more http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/closeread/2011/06/the-road-to-the-gay-girl-in-damascus.html#ixzz1PCxNJYvh

About orvillelloyddouglas

I am a gay black Canadian male.

2 responses to “Shocking Internet Hoax: A Heterosexual Married Man Pretends To Be A Syrian Lesbian On Internet Until He Got Caught!!!”

  1. hemp says :

    We are pretty lesbians in love right? ..Wrong…Yesterday evening Tom MacMaster a 40-year-old American graduate student at the University of Edinburgh in Scotland revealed that Amina — a renowned voice on gay life in Syria and the ongoing popular movement against the Assad regime — was one of several personas he had carefully engineered in what he called a hoax that got way out of hand. ..The torrid love affair the Zina the pale and pretty lesbians in bikinis– all were figments of MacMasters imagination…Amina was well known to big names in American media. But not well known enough…Liz Henry a blogging veteran who says she has uncovered several sockpuppets like MacMasters in her career was instrumental in uncovering the Amina hoax and quite possibly pushing MacMaster to post an apology to the people Aminas words effected… Just simply Googling her turned up slightly odd information Henry said in an interview with the International Business Times…On June 6 a poster on Aminas blog professing to be Aminas cousin Rania said that Amina was kidnapped by what she believed to be plainclothes Syrian security forces loyal to the Assad regime provoking an uproar in mainstream American media and a group calling to Free Amina which had 14 134 followers as of 9 30AM today and 13 809 by 3PM… Media stories about her disappearance had only one source.

  2. Panama foundation says :

    .During the a posting on the blog purportedly by Aminas cousin claimed that Amina was abducted on 6 June 2011. This sparked a strong backlash from the community and was covered widely in mainstream media..In the wake of the reports questions arose regarding the possibility that Arraf al Omari was an elaborate hoax. On June 12 and Benjamin Doherty of the website conducted an investigation that pointed to a strong possibility that the identity of Amina was MacMaster an American living in .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 274 other followers

%d bloggers like this: